Cases and decisions citing the Victorian Reports and Victorian Law Reports
The following list extracts all known citations by Australian and selected international courts of decisions published in the Victorian Reports or Victorian Law Reports. This information is extracted from the JADE Knowledge Graph and is published in this blog each week. Users of the Victorian Reports website are able to see these citations in near real time in the margin or at the top of the page of each cited report.
There were 76 mentions of Victorian Reports and Victorian Law Reports in the period from 06 December 2021 to 12 December 2021.
Mentions
Hanna v Commissioner for Fair Trading [2021] NSWCATOD 198 (06 December 2021)
(S Montgomery, Senior Member)mentionsMotchall v Massoud [1926] VLR 273
(Irvine, C.J)Health Ombudsman v McDowell [2021] QCAT 402 (29 November 2021)
(Judicial Member JM Robertson, Assisted by:, Ms H Barker, Ms L Dyer, Mr P Davies)mentionsR v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
(Maxwell P, Eames and Neave JJA)DPP v Chang (a pseudonym) and Anor [2021] VCC 1869 (18 November 2021)
(HER HONOUR JUDGE HOGAN)mentionsR v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
(Maxwell P, Eames and Neave JJA)Guden v The Queen (2010) 28 VR 288
(Maxwell P, Bongiorno JA and Beach AJA)Brown v The Queen (2019) 59 VR 462
(Maxwell P, Priest, Kaye, T Forrest and Emerton JJA)Brown v The Queen 59 VR 424
(Maxwell P, Priest, Kaye, T Forrest and Emerton JJA)Gold Titan Pty Ltd v Lopez (No 2) [2021] FCA 1523 (3 December 2021)
(ABRAHAM J)mentionsTalbot v General Television Corporation [1980] VR 224
(Marks, J)Mole v Mole (No 2) [2021] VSC 802 (6 December 2021)
(MOORE J)mentionsAvery v Manno (2020) 62 VR 281
(Derham AsJ)Moorabool Valley Eggs Pty Ltd v Seasons Ranch Organic Pty Ltd [2021] VSC 795 (2 December 2021)
(Riordan J)mentionsBradto Pty Ltd v State of Victoria (2006) 15 VR 65
(Maxwell, P. and Charles, J.A)Belgrave Nominees v Barlin-Scott Airconditioning (Aust) [1984] VR 947
(Kaye J)Ibbott v The Queen [2021] VSCA 338 (6 December 2021)
(BEACH JA)mentionsDPP v Meyers (2014) 44 VR 486
(Maxwell P, Redlich and Osborn JJA)R v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
(Maxwell P, Eames and Neave JJA)Hogarth v The Queen (2012) 37 VR 658
(Maxwell P, Neave JA and Coghlan AJA)Clarkson v The Queen (2011) 32 VR 361
(Maxwell ACJ, Nettle, Neave, Redlich and Harper JJA)EFM19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FedCFamC2G 321 (6 December 2021)
(JUDGE EGAN)mentionsHannover Life Re of Australasia Ltd v Colella (2014) 47 VR 1
(Ashley and Beach JJA and Garde AJA)Re Care Super Pty Ltd [2021] VSC 805 (6 December 2021)
(LYONS J)mentionsRe Centro Retail Australia Limited (2012) 35 VR 512
(Almond J)McLean Bros & Rigg Ltd v Grice [1907] VLR 317
(Griffith C.J., Barton and O'Connor JJ.)Re White; Tweedie v Attorney-General (2003) 7 VR 219
(Kellam J)Mango Bonview Pty Ltd v Stonnington CC [2021] VCAT 1471 (10 November 2021)
(9., Before addressing these issues, I set out below brief descriptions of the land, its surrounds and the proposed development.)mentionsMunns v Watson [1937] VLR 178
(Lowe J)Interslice Pty Ltd v CCA Investments – Bass Hill Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 1578 (07 December 2021)
(Ward CJ in Eq)mentionsLivingspring Pty Ltd v Kliger Partners (2008) 20 VR 377
(Maxwell P and Buchanan JA)Opposition by Strathfield Independents to registration of trade mark application number 2018552 (class 45) – STRATHFIELD INDEPENDENTS and device - in the name of Geoffrey Markwell. [2021] ATMO 134 (5 November 2021)
(Nicole Worth)mentionsRe Hicks' Trade Mark (1876) 22 VLR 636
(Holroyd, A’Beckett, and Hood, JJ)Kemperman v Antonenas [2021] NSWSC 1555 (11 November 2021)
(Hallen J)mentionsForsyth v Sinclair (No 2) (2010) 28 VR 635
(Neave and Redlich JJA and Habersberger AJA)Grey v Harrison [1997] 2 VR 359
(Tadgell, Charles and Callaway JJA)DPP v Zotos [2021] VCC 1940 (25 November 2021)
(His Honour Judge Hannebery)mentionsR v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
(Maxwell P, Eames and Neave JJA)R v Knudson [2021] QCA 267 (7 December 2021)
(Fraser and Bond JJA and Kelly J)mentionsR v Murphy [1965] VR 187
(Herring CJ, Sholl and Adam , JJ)R v Tonks and Goss [1963] VR 121
(Herring CJ, Sholl and Little , JJ)R v Maudsley [2021] QCA 268 (7 December 2021)
(McMurdo JA and Daubney and Boddice JJ)mentionsR v Quach (2010) 27 VR 310
(Ashley and Redlich JJA and Hansen AJA)Medical Board of Australia v JUR (Review and Regulation) [2021] VCAT 1474 (6 December 2021)
(J Smithers, Senior Member, Dr L Warfe, Member, Dr P Molloy, Member)mentionsR v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 240
(Maxwell P, Buchanan and Vincent JJA)TAY -v- BUILDING SERVICES BOARD [2021] WASC 433 (7 DECEMBER 2021)
(HILL J)mentionsSecretary to the Department of Premier and Cabinet v Hulls [1999] 3 VR 331
(Tadgell, Phillips and Batt, Jj.A)Paull v The Queen [2021] VSCA 339 (7 December 2021)
(PRIEST, KAYE and NIALL JJA)mentionsR v Flannery [1969] VR 586
(Winneke CJ, Pape and Starke , JJ)Sabbatucci v The Queen [2021] VSCA 340 (7 December 2021)
(MAXWELL P and EMERTON JA)mentionsDPP v Terrick (2009) 24 VR 457
(Maxwell P, Redlich JA and Robson AJA)DPP v PAYNE [2021] VCC 1857 (18 November 2021)
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE CARMODY)mentionsR v Mills [1998] 4 VR 235
(Phillips CJ, Charles and Batt JJA)Australian Capital Financial Management Pty Ltd v Australian Financial Complaints Authority Limited [2021] NSWSC 1577 (07 December 2021)
(Ball J)mentionsMickovski v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd (2012) 36 VR 456
(Buchanan, Nettle JJA and Beach AJA)Environmental Systems Pty Ltd v Peerless Holdings Pty Ltd (2008) 19 VR 358
(Nettle, Ashley and Dodds-Streeton JJA)Bragilevsky v Stonnington CC [2021] VCAT 905 (7 December 2021)
(11., Before the hearing, Alex Bragilevsky also filed an additional drawing prepared by the architects (drawing no. ASK-100 dated 18 March 2021) which provides further detail on the windows proposed to the western elevation about a request by the respondents to limit the opening of those windows. Leave was also sought to include this additional plan as part of the amended plans package.)mentionsShire of Gisborne v King [1994] 1 VR 364
(Nathan J)Hutson v Nerang Subdivision Pty Ltd & ors [2021] QSC 323 (7 December 2021)
(Brown J)mentions1144 Nepean Highway Pty Ltd v Abnote Australasia Pty Ltd (2009) 26 VR 551
(Warren CJ, Nettle and Bongiorno JJA)Small v Maffra Waste Disposal [2021] VMC 17 (21 October 2021)
(M A HOARE)mentionsGrech v Orica Australia Pty Ltd & Anor (2006) 14 VR 602
(Buchanan, Chernov and Ashley, Jj.A)Re HEST Australia Ltd [2021] VSC 809 (7 December 2021)
(Button J)mentionsCargill Australia v Viterra Malt (No 23) (2019) 58 VR 611
(Elliott J)Re Centro Retail Australia Limited (2012) 35 VR 512
(Almond J)Karger v Paul [1984] VR 161
(McGarvie J)Hyland v Medical Council of New South Wales [2021] NSWCATOD 199 (08 December 2021)
(Hennessy ADCJ, Deputy President, Dr A Reid, Senior Member, Dr J Fogarty, Senior Member)mentionsMedical Practitioners Board of Victoria v Lal (2009) 23 VR 702
(Maxwell P, Weinberg JA and Kyrou AJA)Environment Protection Authority v Charlotte Pass Snow Resort Pty Ltd [2021] NSWCCA 289 (08 December 2021)
(Preston CJ of LEC at [1], Price J at [77]; Adamson J at [78])mentionsR v El-Kotob (2002) 4 VR 546
(Callaway and Vincent, Jj.A and O'Bryan, A.J.A)R v Beary (2004) 11 VR 151
(Ormiston, Callaway and Buchanan, Jj.A)McNab v Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) [2021] NSWCA 298 (08 December 2021)
(Bell P at [1]; Basten and McCallum JJA at [43])mentionsR v Gallagher [1998] 2 VR 671
(Brooking and Callaway JJA and Ashley AJA)Kassam v Hazzard; Henry v Hazzard [2021] NSWCA 299 (08 December 2021)
(Bell P at [1]; Meagher JA at [138]; Leeming JA at [139])mentionsWBM v Chief Commissioner of Police (2012) 43 VR 446
(Warren CJ and Hansen JA and Bell AJA)R v Thomas (2006) 14 VR 475
(Maxwell, P., Buchanan and Vincent, Jj.A)Strawhorn v Ballarat CC [2021] VCAT 1482 (6 December 2021)
mentionsGarde-Wilson v Legal Services Board (2008) 19 VR 398
(Buchanan, Nettle and Dodds-Streeton JJA)F & J Investment Assets Pty Ltd v Paul Etcell t/as Ikonic Homes [2021] VCC 1967 (8 December 2021)
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE COSGRAVE)mentionsTrevor Roller Shutter Service Pty Ltd v Crowe (2011) 31 VR 249
(Warren CJ, Nettle and Ashley JJA)DPP v Zhang [2021] VCC 416 (1 December 2021)
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE CAHILL)mentionsHaddara v The Queen (2014) 43 VR 53
(Redlich, Weinberg and Priest JJA)Bell v Tasmania [2021] HCA 42 (8 December 2021)
(KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, KEANE, GORDON, EDELMAN, STEWARD AND GLEESON JJ)mentionsThomas v The King [1938] VLR 32
Re Ratten [1974] VR 201
(Smith , Pape and Adam , JJ)Pharmacy Board of Australia v Trieu (Review and Regulation) [2021] VCAT 1487 (8 December 2021)
(Mr J Billings, Senior Member, Ms V Cogley, Member, Mr R Gymer, Member)mentionsKarakatsanis v Racing Victoria Ltd (2013) 42 VR 176
(Osborn and Beach JJA)Dariusz Koper v Zurich Insurance PLC [2021] NSWSC 1587 (08 December 2021)
(Rein J)mentionsR v Reid [1999] 2 VR 605
(Winneke, P., Buchanan and Chernov, Jj.A)SafeWork NSW v Saunders Civilbuild Pty Ltd [2021] NSWDC 664 (11 November 2021)
(Scotting DCJ)mentionsDirector of Public Prosecutions v Vibro-Pile (Aust) Pty Ltd (2016) 49 VR 676
(Maxwell P, Redlich and Whelan JJA)R v Commercial Industrial Construction Group Pty Ltd (2006) 14 VR 321
(Maxwell, P., Buchanan and Redlich, Jj.A)Dunn v Latrobe City Council (Review and Regulation) [2021] VCAT 1485 (8 December 2021)
(A Dea, Senior Member)mentionsSarwari v Commonwealth Insurance Limited (Civil Claims) [2021] VCAT 1448 (2 December 2021)
(Member D Buljan)mentionsPacific Indemnity Underwriting Agency Pty Ltd v Maclaw No 651 Pty Ltd (2005) 13 VR 483
(Ormiston and Nettle, Jj.A and Hansen, A.J.A)Bottos v CityLink Melbourne Ltd [No 2] [2021] VSC 813 (8 December 2021)
(Gorton J)mentionsO'doherty v McMahon [1971] VR 625
(Winneke, CJ (1 and 2) Gowans and Menhennitt, JJ)McFadzean v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2007) 20 VR 250
(Warren CJ, Nettle and Redlich JJA)Willis v Wilson and MacKINNON [1922] VLR 453
(Irvine, C.J, Cussen, J. and Schutt, J)Byast v The Queen [2021] VSCA 344 (8 December 2021)
(MAXWELL P and EMERTON JA)mentionsHarrison v The Queen (2015) 49 VR 619
(Maxwell P, Redlich and Tate JJA)Harrison v The Queen (2015) 74 MVR 58
(Maxwell P, Redlich and Tate JJA)Davis v Department of Health (Review and Regulation) [2021] VCAT 1490 (9 December 2021)
(R. Tang AM, Member)mentionsMcKechnie v VCAT (2020) 62 VR 54
(Cavanough J)Health Care Complaints Commission v McCarthy [2021] NSWCATOD 201 (09 December 2021)
(The Hon F Marks Principal Member, Dr L Gregory Senior Member, M Rowles Senior Member, B Seth General Member)mentionsThe King v Jenkins [1949] VLR 277
(Full Court (Herring C.J, Lowe and Fullagar Jj))Veira v Cook [2021] NSWCA 302 (09 December 2021)
(Basten JA at [1]; Meagher JA at [2]; Emmett AJA at [51])mentionsR v Loughnan [1981] VR 443
(Young, CJ, Crockett and King, JJ)REGISTRAR OF THE DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v FRYER [2021] SADC 135 (30 November 2021)
(Judge Burnett)mentionsIN THE MATTER OF THE CORONERS ACT 1890 (1876) 24 VLR 957
(Madden, C.J, A’Beckett and Hodges, JJ)Kalmas & Kalmas [2021] FedCFamC2F 208 (21 October 2021)
(JUDGE BURCHARDT)mentionsOgilvie v Adams [1981] VR 1041
(Fullagar, J)Collins v Registrar of Firearms [2021] SACAT 66 (6 November 2021)
(Member Ward)mentionsState of Victoria v Seal Rocks Victoria (Australia) Pty Ltd (2001) 3 VR 1
(Ormiston, Phillips and Buchanan, Jj.A)CDPP v ISIK [2021] VCC 1973 (8 December 2021)
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE CAHILL)mentionsHaddara v The Queen (2014) 43 VR 53
(Redlich, Weinberg and Priest JJA)DPP v Paulino (2017) 54 VR 109
(Weinberg, Priest and Ferguson JJA)Opposition by Publishing ByChelle Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application number 2027292 (classes 9, 38, 41) – AUSBIZ – in the name of Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd [2021] ATMO 130 (1 November 2021)
(Nicholas Barbey)mentionsRe Hicks' Trade Mark (1876) 22 VLR 636
(Holroyd, A’Beckett, and Hood, JJ)Chamoun v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2021] VCC 1924 (3 December 2021)
(HER HONOUR JUDGE K L BOURKE)mentionsBarwon Spinners Pty Ltd & Ors v Podolak (2005) 14 VR 622
(Ormiston, Chernov & Phillips Jj.A)Haden Engineering Pty Ltd v McKinnon (2010) 31 VR 1
(Maxwell P, Buchanan and Nettle JJA)Church v Echuca Regional Health (2008) 20 VR 566
(Buchanan and Ashley JJA and Pagone AJA)Kelso v Tatiara Meat Co Pty Ltd (2007) 17 VR 592
(Buchanan, Nettle, Ashley, Kellam and Dodds-Streeton, JJA)Antonopoulos v Transport Accident Commission [2021] VCC 1939 (8 December 2021)
(HER HONOUR JUDGE K BOURKE)mentionsRichards v Wylie (2000) 1 VR 79
(Winneke, P., Buchanan and Chernov, Jj.A)Haden Engineering Pty Ltd v McKinnon (2010) 31 VR 1
(Maxwell P, Buchanan and Nettle JJA)Kelso v Tatiara Meat Co Pty Ltd (2007) 17 VR 592
(Buchanan, Nettle, Ashley, Kellam and Dodds-Streeton, JJA)Cachia v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2021] VCC 1925 (8 December 2021)
(HER HONOUR JUDGE TRAN)mentionsTilahun Yirga-Denbu v Victorian WorkCover Authority (2018) 57 VR 545
(Priest, Beach and Niall JJA)Haden Engineering Pty Ltd v McKinnon (2010) 31 VR 1
(Maxwell P, Buchanan and Nettle JJA)Panagi & Panagi [2021] FedCFamC1F 135 (15 October 2021)
(HARPER J)mentionsLysaght Building Solutions Pty Ltd v Blanalko Pty Ltd (2013) 42 VR 27
(Warren CJ, Nettle and Neave JJA)Stylianos & Stylianos [2021] FedCFamC1F 145 (21 October 2021)
(WILSON J)mentionsByrns v DAVIE [1991] 2 VR 568
(Gobbo J)GANGEMI -v- SPARTA [2021] WASC 441 (9 DECEMBER 2021)
(MASTER SANDERSON)mentionsRe Plowright, Deceased [1971] VR 128
(Newton, J)Willans & Enmore (No 2) [2021] FedCFamC1F 130 (14 October 2021)
(WILSON J)mentionsVerna Trading v New India Assurance Co [1991] 1 VR 129
(Beach , Kaye , McGarvie and Ormiston JJ)Popal v Panda Care Pty Ltd [2021] VSC 812 (8 December 2021)
(Ginnane J)mentionsRichter v Driscoll (2016) 51 VR 95
(Ashley, Osborn and Kaye JJA)El-Najjar v Swidryk Investments Pty Ltd [2021] VSC 814 (9 December 2021)
(Richards J)mentionsChang v Neill (2019) 62 VR 174
(Maxwell ACJ, Beach and Kyrou JJA)D'Sylva v Ellenbrook Family Medical Centre Pty Ltd [2021] FedCFamC2G 319 (8 December 2021)
(JUDGE LUCEV)mentionsBrown v Maurice Blackburn Cashman (2013) 45 VR 22
(Harper and Osborn JJA and Macaulay AJA)R v Ibrahim [2021] NSWCCA 296 (10 December 2021)
(Johnson J at [1], Lonergan J at [5], Dhanji J at [6])mentionsMarkovic v The Queen (2010) 30 VR 589
(Maxwell P, Nettle, Neave, Redlich and Weinberg JJA)Zonnevylle v Information Commissioner [2021] NSWCATAD 366 (10 December 2021)
(H J Dixon SC, Senior Member)mentionsState Electricity Commission of Victoria v Rabel [1998] 1 VR 102
(Tadgell, Ormiston and Phillips JJA)TLP v Director General, Department of Justice and Attorney General [2021] QCAT 411 (3 December 2021)
(Member Pennell)mentionsRe Imperial Chemical Industries 's Patent Extension Petitions [1983] 1 VR 1
(Fullagar, J,)Wilson & Anor v Richards & Ors (No 4) (Costs Ruling) [2021] VCC 1977 (10 December 2021)
(HER HONOUR JUDGE A RYAN)mentionsByrns v DAVIE [1991] 2 VR 568
(Gobbo J)Director of Public Prosecutions (Cth) v Knight [2021] VCC 1927 (23 November 2021)
(HER HONOUR JUDGE MORRISH)mentionsR v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
(Maxwell P, Eames and Neave JJA)BTH v Tasmania [2021] TASCCA 14 (10 December 2021)
(Estcourt J, Geason J, Martin AJ)mentionsR v Miletic [1997] 1 VR 593
(Winneke P, Charles and Callaway JJA)Grasso Consulting Engineers Pty Ltd v SafeWork NSW; Grasso v SafeWork NSW [2021] NSWCCA 288 (10 December 2021)
(Simpson AJA at [1], Walton J at [9], Cavanagh J at [38])mentionsDirector of Public Prosecutions v Vibro-Pile (Aust) Pty Ltd (2016) 49 VR 676
(Maxwell P, Redlich and Whelan JJA)Willcocks v Croft [2021] NSWSC 1610 (10 December 2021)
(Harrison AsJ)mentionsClark v Clark 8 VLR (E) 303
(MOLESWORTH, Higinbotham, and HOLROYD, JJ.)DPP v Chapman (a pseudonym) [2021] VCC 1321 (17 September 2021)
(Her Honour Judge Brimer)mentionsDavid Edward Rapson v The Queen (2014) 45 VR 103
(Maxwell P, Nettle, Beach JJA)Ramon Harris (a Pseudonym)[1] v The Queen (2015) 44 VR 652
(Priest and Kaye JJA and Croucher AJA)CGL v DPP (2010) 24 VR 486
(Maxwell P, Buchanan and Bongiorno JJA)DPP v Purcell [2021] VCC 1807 (18 November 2021)
(HIS HONOUR JUDGE TIWANA)mentionsR v Verdins (2007) 16 VR 269
(Maxwell P, Eames and Neave JJA)DPP v Neethling (2009) 22 VR 466
(Maxwell P, Vincent JA and Hargrave AJA)Stephens v The Queen (2016) 50 VR 740
(Redlich, Santamaria and Beach JJA)Stephens v The Queen (2016) 76 MVR 90
(Redlich, Santamaria and Beach JJA)Vision Precast Pty Ltd & Ors v Ferguson & Ors [2021] VSC 808 (8 December 2021)
(Daly AsJ)mentionsDPP v Leys (2012) 44 VR 1
(Redlich and Tate JJA and T Forrest AJA)Chang v Neill (2019) 62 VR 174
(Maxwell ACJ, Beach and Kyrou JJA)DPP v Moreno (2018) 57 VR 1
(Daly AsJ)Trani v Trani (No 3) (2020) 62 VR 33
(Daly AsJ)Williams v Orora Packaging Australia Pty Ltd (Human Rights) [2021] VCAT 1488 (10 December 2021)
(Deputy President G. Nihill)mentionsTowie v Victoria (2008) 19 VR 640
(Kyrou J)WEQ (a pseudonym) v Medical Board of Australia [2021] VSCA 343 (8 December 2021)
(KYROU and McLEISH JJA)mentionsLew v Priester (No. 2) (2012) 35 VR 216
(Davies J)MSB (a pseudonym) v Chief Commissioner of Police (2018) 57 VR 360
(Maxwell P, McLeish JA and Almond AJA)PQR v Secretary, Department of Justice and Regulation (No 1) (2017) 53 VR 45
(Bell J)The Herald and Weekly Times v Magistrates' Court of Victo ria [1999] 2 VR 672
(Beach, J)The Herald and Weekly Times v Medical Practitioners Board of Victoria [1999] 1 VR 267
(Hedigan J)Botsman v Bolitho (2018) 57 VR 68
(Tate, Whelan and Niall JJA)Wilcox v Chapple (No 2) [2021] NSWSC 1607 (10 December 2021)
(Robb J)mentionsBishopsgate Insurance Australia (In liq) v Deloitte Haskins and Sells [1999] 3 VR 863
(Brooking, Tadgell and Ormiston JJ)Masel v Transport Industries Insurance Co [1995] 2 VR 328
(Brooking , Teague and Hedigan JJ)McKenna v McKenna [1984] VR 665
(Anderson, Murray and McGarvie JJ)Allison v Murphy [2021] FCA 1551 (9 December 2021)
(DOWNES J)mentionsSmail v Burton Re Insurance Associates (In Liquidation) [1975] VR 776
(Gillard, Newton and Norris, JJ)EPU19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (No 2) [2021] FCA 1536 (10 December 2021)
(PERRY J)mentionsO'Donnell v Reichard [1975] VR 916
(Gillard, Newton and Norris JJ)RESOURCE RECOVERY SOLUTIONS PTY LTD ‑v- AYTON [2021] WASC 443 (10 DECEMBER 2021)
(SMITH J)mentionsToyota Motor Corporation Australia v Ken Morgan Motors [1994] 2 VR 106
(Brooking , Tadgell and JD Phillips , JJ)